SFPD Officer Found Guilty of Illegal Search

SFPD Henry Hotel Raid Dec. 23, 2014

An image from Henry Hotel security camera footage shows SFPD Officer Arthur Madrid inserting a key into the door of room 504. Officer Arshad Razzak is directly to Madrid’s right, and Officer Richard Yick is in the foreground. Madrid’s partner, Robert Forenis, is to his left. (Courtesy of the San Francisco Public Defender’s Office)

By Alex Emslie
KQED

Update, 12:45 p.m.: A jury has convicted San Francisco police Officer Arshad Razzak on federal charges for illegally searching the room of drug suspects. Razzak was also charged with falsifying a police report to make the warrantless search appear legal. Fellow plainclothes officer Richard Yick was found not guilty.

Original:
A federal jury began deliberations Wednesday in a criminal trial of two San Francisco plainclothes police officers charged with conspiring to illegally search the hotel rooms of drug suspects.

The charges against officers Arshad Razzak and Richard Yick stem from a warrantless entry into a hotel room on Dec. 23, 2010. Razzak allegedly got a tip from a confidential informant that a male and a female were in Room 504 at the Henry Hotel, a single-room-occupancy hotel on Sixth Street, with a large quantity of heroin.

Razzak and Yick met two other Southern District plainclothes officers, Arthur Madrid and Robert Forenis, outside the hotel. Madrid and Forenis specialized in auto burglaries, but the plainclothes unit was short that day so they showed up to assist in the raid. The four launched a loose plan to secure the room and then get a search warrant, according to Yick’s testimony.

But a search warrant was never part of the plan, federal prosecutors said, and instead officers were engaged in a conspiracy to violate civil rights of drug suspects.

In his closing arguments, federal prosecutor Rodney Villazor described how a “run-of-the-mill” narcotics possession case became part of an ongoing black eye for the SFPD, when in March 2011 the San Francisco Public Defender’s Office released Henry Hotel security camera footage of the raid.

It’s the second federal criminal trial against SFPD plainclothes officers in recent months as investigations into the videos make their way through the criminal justice system. Two other officers were convicted of taking money from drug suspects and pocketing it, among other charges, in December. They have not yet been sentenced.

“What was on the video was irreconcilable with what was in the police report,” Villazor told the jury. “Why? Because Arshad Razzak was falsifying, falsifying it to cover up their actions … to go into Jessica Richmond’s room without a warrant.”

Defense attorneys argued officers had the right to enter the room without a warrant because there were exigent circumstances, an exception to the Fourth Amendment’s warrant requirement. Police had reason to believe the heroin would be moved, and soon. But the raid became confused, with some officers testifying they believed they would “freeze” the room from outside and get a warrant, while at least one of the officers thought the plan was to enter the apartment.

‘Freeze the Room’ or ‘Key the Door?’

The security camera video shows four officers, Yick in front, charging onto the fifth floor of the Henry Hotel. Yick covers one of the cameras with his hand while the other three officers pass him. He testified that this was common practice, to keep the hotel’s desk clerk from alerting residents that police were coming.

But there were other cameras.

With Madrid now in the lead, the officers turned a corner and approached Room 504. Somehow, Madrid had a master key, but none of the officers who testified could remember how he got it, including Madrid.

Yick testified that he understood the idea to “freeze the room” to mean to lock it down from the outside, he said.

But as he rounded the corner, he saw Madrid walk directly to the door with Forenis and Razzak behind him. He appeared to immediately insert the key and open the door.

“It wasn’t the plan,” Yick testified. “That’s not freezing the room.”

Federal prosecutors granted Madrid immunity from prosecution in the case in exchange for his testimony. He said Razzak told him to “key the door.” Yick and Forenis said they never heard that order. Razzak did not testify.

The video shows Madrid pushing into the room with Forenis on his left, Razzak and Yick on his right.

As soon as he noticed Madrid opening the door, Yick testified, he switched his role from “freezing the room” to backup for the entry.

“Once someone’s going in, your first role is to back that officer up,” Yick said. “This is where you can get killed.”

According to federal prosecutors, the moment officers entered the room without a search warrant, a conspiracy to violate the civil rights of the resident had launched.

“The real plan was just to enter the room,” Villazor told the jury. “They were not going to freeze it. … This is the moment. This is the part they want to cover up.”

Razzak’s defense attorney, Michael Rains, told the jury that officers were doing their job lawfully, as they understood it. He showed Razzak’s training records and argued the senior officer had very little training on the key issue.

“In the last week,” Rains told the jury, “you have heard more about securing a room pending the issuance of a search warrant and exigent circumstances than these defendants have heard in 16 years.”

He added, “He got no training. They’re throwing this guy into hotel rooms … and he’s doing the best he can.”

‘Paper it After’

The officers pulled Carlos Hutcherson and the registered occupant, Jessica Richmond, from the room. Yick said uncapped needles were strewn about the floor and covering the bed. Hutcherson was arrested for possession of some 65 grams of heroin, but a San Francisco Superior Court judge dismissed the case in light of the security camera footage. Scores of other cases were also dropped in the wake of the SFPD video scandal, which includes other incidents in which footage appears to contradict official police reports.

In the Henry Hotel case, Razzak wrote that officers knocked and announced their presence and were met by Richmond at the door, who gave them consent to search the apartment. Richmond did sign a consent-to-search form, brought to the hotel later by two uniformed SFPD officers, but she testified she was coerced into signing it.

“The real plan was to enter the room and then paper it after,” Villazor said, meaning officers intended to create an official paper trail of falsified records to justify the search. “Possibly the most flawed part to this freezing-the-room fantasy: They had a hotel key.”

Defense attorneys argued the charges are a stretch. The officers may have made mistakes, but they intended to do their job lawfully.

“When people conspire, they do not conspire in one limited incident in a case of limited significance against people they do not know,” said Yick’s attorney, Peter Furst.

Intent is a key element in every charge against both Razzak and Yick. To be found guilty of conspiracy, they must not only have agreed to enter the room without a warrant, but also to have done so with the intent of violating Richmond’s Fourth Amendment protection against unreasonable search and seizure, according to the court’s instructions to jurors.

Both officers are also charged with deprivation of rights under the color of law.

The most serious charges involve only Razzak and his alleged intentional falsification of a police report and informant pay slip about the incident. Yick was originally charged with similar counts, but both have been dropped over the course of the trial.

The jury is scheduled to resume deliberating today.

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s